Biblical Stewardship: Managing Church Finances with Integrity

Nobody talks about this story, but it needs to be told.

A church I worked with discovered their treasurer had been skimming for eight years. Eight years. The guy taught Sunday school, led prayer meetings, had keys to everything. When the new treasurer finally started digging through the books, she found nearly $200,000 missing. Deposits that didn't match giving records. Transfers that went nowhere. Documentation that should have existed but mysteriously didn't.

The money hurt. What hurt worse was the fallout. Members who'd given sacrificially felt betrayed. The community whispered. People left. The pastor spent two years doing damage control instead of ministry. And honestly? The whole thing was preventable.

I'm not telling you this to scare you. I'm telling you because most churches operate on trust, and trust without systems is just wishful thinking.

Let's Get the Theology Right First

Here's the thing that should change how you think about church money: none of it is yours. Not the church's, not the pastor's, not the board's. Every dollar that comes through the offering plate belongs to God. The church is just the steward.

When you actually believe this, it changes everything. Budget meetings stop being political battles over who gets what. They become conversations about "How does God want His resources used?" Spending decisions carry real weight because they represent people's worship—families who sacrificed to give that money.

And transparency becomes non-negotiable. If the resources belong to God and come from His people, those people deserve to know where their gifts go. Churches that hide behind minimal disclosure requirements? They're missing the point entirely.

The Basics That Prevent Disaster

Look, I know written financial policies sound bureaucratic. But here's what happens without them: procedures exist only in people's heads, and when those people leave, the procedures leave with them. Gaps open up. Things get missed. And sometimes worse.

Counting the offering: Multiple people. Always. Never one person alone with cash. Count it immediately, record the amounts, deposit within 24 hours. This isn't about distrust—it's about protecting everyone, including the people counting.

Spending money: Clear thresholds for who can approve what. $100 purchase? Maybe any staff can approve. $5,000? Needs the board. Whatever your numbers are, write them down. Require receipts before reimbursement, not after.

Separation of duties: This is the big one. The person receiving money shouldn't deposit it. The person writing checks shouldn't reconcile the bank statement. The person approving invoices shouldn't enter them into the system. When one person controls an entire process, you're asking for trouble—even if that person is wonderful. Especially if that person is wonderful, because nobody's watching.

About That Budget

Most church budgets are lazy. (I can say that because I've written some lazy ones myself.)

What usually happens: someone pulls up last year's budget, adds 3% to everything, argues about a couple line items, and calls it done. But this just perpetuates whatever problems existed last year, plus inflation.

Better approach: Ask uncomfortable questions. That women's breakfast that's been running since 1987—does it still make sense? That missions line item that hasn't changed since the Clinton administration—is it even going to the same place? That software subscription nobody's logged into for six months—why are we paying for it?

Starting from scratch, at least conceptually, forces you to justify every dollar. It's uncomfortable. It's also necessary.

On predicting income: Be honest, not hopeful. Looking at three years of data beats looking at one. If giving has declined 3% annually for five years, don't budget for growth because you're "believing for a turnaround." Hope isn't a financial strategy.

On reserves: I know, reserves aren't sexy. "We could be doing ministry with that money!" But the church with three months of expenses in the bank survives surprises. The church living paycheck to paycheck doesn't. Build the cushion before you expand the ministry.

The Salary Conversation Nobody Wants to Have

Most churches dramatically underpay their staff. And look, I get it—there's this weird guilt thing around church workers making "too much." But here's what actually happens when you underpay people: they leave. After two years, because they can't pay their student loans. And then you spend months hiring and training replacements, lose all that institutional knowledge, and probably spend more over time than if you'd just paid fairly.

Fair compensation means:

• Actual market-rate salary (not "well, they get to work for God")
• Health insurance (sick staff can't minister)
• Retirement contributions (they'll need to eat when they're 70)
• Professional development (even pastors need to learn)

Yes, it's expensive. That's why you budget for it.

When Money Gets Tight

Every church faces a financial crunch eventually. Here's what not to do: send a panicked email about "dire financial straits." Nothing tanks giving faster than making people lose confidence in the church's management.

What works better: "We're adjusting our budget to match current giving patterns." Same information, totally different energy.

When you have to cut, cut strategically. Across-the-board 10% cuts sound fair but usually aren't. Some ministries can absorb cuts easily; others get crippled. Make actual decisions. And don't slash staff first unless you've exhausted other options—cutting the children's director to save $40K means you no longer have a children's ministry. Was that really the smartest cut?

Transparency Matters More Than You Think

Churches that hide their finances breed suspicion. "What are they doing with our money?" People fill in the blanks with their imaginations, and imaginations are rarely generous.

Churches that share financial information openly—quarterly updates, accessible annual reports, clear explanations—build trust. And people give more generously to organizations they trust.

You don't need fancy graphics. You just need honesty: "Here's what we received, here's what we spent it on, here's how it's going." That's enough.

The Real Point

Financial health isn't about having a lot of money. It's about using whatever you have wisely, planning for what you can see coming, and building systems that protect everyone.

That treasurer who embezzled for eight years? He probably didn't start out planning to steal. Somewhere along the way, opportunity met temptation, and nobody was watching. Good systems protect against that—not because everyone is a thief, but because everyone is human.

Build the policies. Require the oversight. Demand the transparency. Not because you're suspicious of people, but because you're serious about stewardship.

The money people give represents real sacrifice. They could have bought new shoes for their kids or taken a vacation or fixed their car. Instead, they gave it to your church because they believed in what you're doing. That trust deserves to be honored with visible, consistent, professional management.

That's really all there is to it.

---

What's worked for your church's financial management? What's been a total disaster? Share in the comments—we learn more from each other's failures than successes.